The Advocate’s Edge

As a new attorney, you’re likely to encounter conflict with opposing counsel as part of your everyday practice. These interactions can sometimes feel like battles rather than professional exchanges. However, maintaining a respectful and cooperative attitude with the other side not only reflects well on you but can also lead to better outcomes for your client and a more manageable work life for yourself. Here are some strategies to help you navigate these conflicts effectively:

1. Remember: They’re Just Doing Their Job

It’s easy to get caught up in the heat of the moment and take opposing counsel’s actions personally. However, it’s important to remember that, like you, they are simply trying to do their job and represent their client’s interests. Very rarely is it about you personally. If it seems personal, it’s often due to something that matters deeply to them, much like how you invest in your cases.

Try to be patient and focus on areas where you can find common ground. For instance, instead of dwelling on disagreements, work together to schedule depositions or extend deadlines. These small steps can help build a cooperative relationship and make the litigation process smoother.

2. Don’t React Emotionally or Immediately

In the heat of legal disputes, it’s natural to feel a surge of emotions. However, reacting impulsively or letting your emotions dictate your responses can be detrimental. Maintaining a professional image is crucial in every interaction, and this includes how you handle conflicts with opposing counsel.

1. Pause Before Responding

When faced with a provocative statement or a challenging situation, take a moment to breathe and compose yourself before responding. Immediate reactions often lead to heightened emotions and potentially regrettable comments. Instead, give yourself time to reflect on the best course of action. This pause can help you formulate a more measured and effective response.

2. Separate Personal Feelings from Professional Duties

It’s essential to distinguish between personal feelings and professional responsibilities. While some situations may genuinely warrant a passionate response, it’s important to remember that you are representing not just yourself but your client and the legal profession as a whole. Engaging in personal attacks or insults undermines your credibility and can escalate conflicts unnecessarily.

3. Focus on the Issue, Not the Person

When addressing conflicts, keep the discussion centered on the issues at hand rather than attacking the opposing counsel personally. Criticize the arguments or actions, not the individual. This approach not only maintains a level of professionalism but also helps in finding constructive solutions rather than deepening the conflict.

4. Acknowledge When Emotions Are Warranted

There are times when expressing emotion can be effective, such as when passionately defending your client’s rights or highlighting a significant injustice. However, these moments should be deliberate and measured, not reactive. Aim to communicate with conviction without crossing the line into personal or disrespectful remarks.

5. Set a Positive Example

By handling conflicts with professionalism and composure, you set a positive example for others in the legal community. Your approach to difficult situations can influence how others interact with you and can contribute to a more respectful and productive legal environment.

3. Switch to Writing-Only Communication

When tensions run high, consider moving to writing-only communication. Sterile, well-crafted emails can help keep discussions focused on the issues at hand, minimizing emotional responses. Written communication can act as a cooling-off period, helping everyone refocus on their professional responsibilities. Plus, the formality of written exchanges often encourages attorneys to moderate their tone and behavior, as everything is documented and can be reviewed later.

4. Acknowledge Personal Lives

Everyone has off days, and sometimes an attorney’s uncharacteristic behavior might not be about you or the case at all. It could be influenced by stress from personal life or other external factors. Reflecting on your own chaotic days, you might find that minor conflicts with opposing counsel are just a small part of a larger picture. Showing grace and understanding can go a long way in maintaining a professional relationship and alleviating unnecessary stress.

5. Maintain Healthy Boundaries

Offering grace doesn’t mean you should overlook unprofessional behavior. It’s essential to uphold boundaries and expect a certain level of professionalism. If an attorney’s behavior is out of line, address it appropriately. Apologies can be part of the process, and it’s important to acknowledge when they’re warranted. Similarly, if you find yourself in the wrong, don’t hesitate to apologize and make amends.

Final Thoughts

Navigating conflict with opposing counsel is a crucial skill in your legal career. By maintaining respect, practicing patience, focusing on written communication when necessary, and understanding the personal pressures everyone faces, you can handle disputes more effectively. Remember, your goal is to advocate for your client while also contributing to a professional and cooperative legal environment. Keeping these strategies in mind will help you manage conflicts gracefully and improve your overall experience as an attorney.

Don’t forget to subscribe below to receive articles like this & more straight to your inbox from The Young Attorney!